LockhelmIntroductions to password, identity and access tools

Customer identity (CIAM) · 6 tools

Top 6 customer identity tools for keeping costs predictable as users grow

By the Lockhelm editorial team · Published · Updated · Facts checked 21 November 2026 (Asia/Dhaka)

If you want authentication spend to stay predictable as your user base grows, start with FusionAuth, SuperTokens and Ory, three tools you can run on infrastructure you control. Firebase Authentication, Amazon Cognito and Microsoft Entra External ID follow as managed cloud services. This shortlist is for consumer apps and startups that are scaling monthly active users and want to understand their deployment options before committing.

At a glance: the shortlist in order of fit for this use case
#ToolBest forKey featurePlatforms / deploymentPricingMore
1FusionAuthFusionAuthTeams that want to choose where their identity system runsAuthentication and user management with SSO, MFA, OAuth2 and OpenID ConnectSelf-hosted, dedicated, on-prem, hybrid and FusionAuth CloudSee vendor pricing pageIntroduction
2SuperTokensSuperTokensStartups that want an open source auth layer with a prebuilt UIMagic links, SSO, social, passwordless and email-password loginNot stated on official pagesSee vendor pricing pageOfficial site
3OryOry CorpTeams that want headless identity with a choice of self-hosting or a managed serviceOpen-source components that run on your own infrastructureSelf-hosted, Ory Network (SaaS), on-prem, private cloud and air-gappedSee vendor pricing pageIntroduction
4Firebase AuthenticationGoogleMobile and web teams already building on FirebaseEmail/password, phone auth and several social providersiOS, Android, web, C++ and UnitySee vendor pricing pageIntroduction
5Amazon CognitoAmazon Web ServicesAWS-based teams that want a managed CIAM serviceUser pools, tenant-based identity stores that scale to millions of usersManaged AWS service; works with many developer frameworks and languagesSee vendor pricing pageIntroduction
6Microsoft Entra External IDMicrosoftOrganizations already in the Microsoft ecosystem that need external identitiesB2B collaboration with partners using their own credentials via invitation and redemptionNot stated on official pagesSee vendor pricing pageIntroduction

1 FusionAuth

By FusionAuth

FusionAuth is an API-first customer identity and access management (CIAM) platform offering authentication, SSO, MFA and user management. It can be self-hosted or hosted.

Why it is here: It comes first because its documentation stresses deployment anywhere, including self-hosted, dedicated, on-prem and hybrid, which gives teams the most direct control over their identity footprint as users grow.

Best for
Teams that want to choose where their identity system runs
Key features
  • Authentication and user management with SSO, MFA, OAuth2 and OpenID Connect
  • Self-hosted, dedicated, on-prem and hybrid deployment models
  • Every identity capability exposed through an API
  • Integrates with CI/CD and Terraform workflows
  • Supports B2C, B2B, B2B2C, partner, API and machine-to-machine user models
Limits
The vendor documents a dedicated single-tenant architecture, so teams expecting a shared multi-tenant service should confirm how that fits their setup. Teams with specific compliance needs should check the vendor documentation for their case.
Platforms / deployment
Self-hosted, dedicated, on-prem, hybrid and FusionAuth Cloud
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

2 SuperTokens

By SuperTokens

SuperTokens is an open source user authentication provider that lets developers add login, sessions and multi-tenancy to their apps. It follows an open core model, and its whole codebase is source available.

Why it is here: It sits second because the open source, source-available codebase lets startups inspect and run the software themselves, though the vendor documents fewer deployment variants than FusionAuth.

Best for
Startups that want an open source auth layer with a prebuilt UI
Key features
  • Magic links, SSO, social, passwordless and email-password login
  • Prebuilt UI that can be customized in any part
  • Multi-tenancy with a separate user pool per tenant
  • Migration with bulk and lazy strategies that avoid forced password changes or logouts
  • User management dashboard for password resets, session revocation and role changes
Limits
Documented as an open core product with a source-available codebase. Teams that need a specific hosting arrangement should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms / deployment
Not stated on official pages
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

3 Ory

By Ory Corp

Ory is a cloud-native, API-first and self-hostable identity and access management platform for applications, enterprises and AI agents. Its open-source components can run on your own infrastructure.

Why it is here: It follows the first two because it offers both self-hosted building blocks and a fully managed service, so teams can start in one model and keep the other available.

Best for
Teams that want headless identity with a choice of self-hosting or a managed service
Key features
  • Open-source components that run on your own infrastructure
  • Ory Network as a fully managed SaaS option
  • Enterprise License for on-prem, private cloud and air-gapped deployment
  • Headless design that leaves UI/UX in your hands
  • Built-in observability, including metrics and trace-level log correlation
Limits
The headless design means your team builds the user interface. CVE SLAs, support and proprietary features are documented as part of the Enterprise License, so check which edition covers your needs.
Platforms / deployment
Self-hosted, Ory Network (SaaS), on-prem, private cloud and air-gapped
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

4 Firebase Authentication

By Google

Firebase Authentication is Google's backend service, SDK and UI library offering for authenticating users in mobile and web apps. It supports email/password, phone auth and several social providers.

Why it is here: It sits in the managed-service group because it runs on Google Cloud as a hosted product, which suits teams that prefer less infrastructure work over control of deployment.

Best for
Mobile and web teams already building on Firebase
Key features
  • Email/password, phone auth and several social providers
  • FirebaseUI, a customizable open source drop-in sign-in UI
  • Account merging with minimal code
  • SDKs for iOS, Android, web, C++ and Unity
  • Pairs with Cloud Firestore and Hosting, with security rules limiting data access
Limits
Documented as a Google-hosted product within the Firebase platform. Teams that need to self-host or deploy on-prem should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms / deployment
iOS, Android, web, C++ and Unity
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

5 Amazon Cognito

By Amazon Web Services

Amazon Cognito is a fully managed AWS authentication service for customer identity and access management. It secures sign-in and access control for users, AI agents and microservices.

Why it is here: It comes after the self-hostable options because it is a fully managed AWS service, which fits teams already on AWS that want identity handled for them.

Best for
AWS-based teams that want a managed CIAM service
Key features
  • User pools, tenant-based identity stores that scale to millions of users
  • Social login and passwordless login with WebAuthn passkeys or SMS and email one-time passwords
  • MFA via email, SMS or TOTP authenticator apps
  • Federation with social providers and enterprise providers via SAML and OIDC
  • Lambda triggers and custom authentication flows
Limits
Documented as a managed AWS service, so teams that need self-hosting should look elsewhere on this list. Passkey storage is documented at up to 20 per account.
Platforms / deployment
Managed AWS service; works with many developer frameworks and languages
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

6 Microsoft Entra External ID

By Microsoft

Microsoft Entra External ID manages external identities, covering B2B guest collaboration for workforce tenants and CIAM for consumer apps.

Why it is here: It sits last because its documentation spends much of its length on guest and partner collaboration, with consumer sign-up covered more briefly, which makes it a narrower fit for scaling a consumer app.

Best for
Organizations already in the Microsoft ecosystem that need external identities
Key features
  • B2B collaboration with partners using their own credentials via invitation and redemption
  • Self-service sign-up user flows
  • Custom sign-up and sign-in experiences for consumer scenarios
  • MSAL, the open-source library Microsoft recommends
  • Programmatic management with PowerShell and related SCIM provisioning docs
Limits
Documented mainly for guest collaboration and consumer sign-up within the Microsoft identity platform. Teams building large consumer apps should check the vendor documentation for the CIAM scenarios they need.
Platforms / deployment
Not stated on official pages
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

How we chose these tools

We looked at three things: fit with the use case of keeping authentication costs predictable as user counts rise, the capabilities each vendor documents, and the deployment and platform options described on its official pages. For this use case, the deployment model matters because tools you can self-host or run on dedicated resources give you more control over what you run and where. Managed cloud services trade that control for less operational work. We do not compare prices here. Each vendor's pricing page is the place to check how its charges are structured.

The order reflects editorial fit for this use case, and we explain each position in words. Tools that can be self-hosted or deployed on your own infrastructure come first, and managed cloud services follow. A position does not say one tool is better overall, and a tool lower on the list may suit your team well if you already work in its ecosystem. Every fact comes from official vendor pages and is tied to the date we checked it. The list is built from documentation rather than product trials, so confirm details with each vendor before you decide.

Order used in this guide: Ordered by cost control, with self-hostable or flat-pricing options ahead of per-MAU cloud services.

Frequently asked questions

What does it mean to keep authentication costs predictable?

It means choosing a deployment and vendor model where growth in monthly active users does not surprise you. Self-hostable tools such as FusionAuth, SuperTokens and Ory let you run the software on your own infrastructure, while managed services handle operations for you. Check each vendor's pricing page for how it charges.

Which tools on this list can be self-hosted?

FusionAuth documents self-hosted, dedicated, on-prem and hybrid deployment. Ory's open-source components can run on your own infrastructure, and SuperTokens is open source with a source-available codebase. Firebase Authentication, Amazon Cognito and Microsoft Entra External ID are described as managed offerings.

Can I migrate existing users without forcing password resets?

SuperTokens documents bulk and lazy migration strategies that avoid forced password changes or logouts, and its imports cover password hashes, TOTP secrets and roles. Check each other vendor's documentation for its own migration options.

Is Amazon Cognito suited to large user counts?

Cognito documents user pools, tenant-based identity stores that scale to millions of users. It is a fully managed AWS service, so it suits teams that want AWS to run the infrastructure.

Does Ory offer a managed option as well as self-hosting?

Yes. Ory Network is a fully managed cloud IAM service delivered as SaaS, and the open-source components can run on your own infrastructure. The Ory Enterprise License adds on-prem, private cloud and air-gapped deployment with premium support.

Sources. Facts on this page come from each vendor's official pages, checked on the dates shown (Asia/Dhaka):

Lockhelm is independent and not affiliated with the vendors listed. No vendor paid for inclusion or position. Product names belong to their owners. Features and prices change; confirm details on each official website.