LockhelmIntroductions to password, identity and access tools

Multi-factor authentication · 5 tools

Top 5 MFA tools for protecting legacy apps and service accounts without native MFA

By the Lockhelm editorial team · Published · Updated · Facts checked 21 November 2026 (Asia/Dhaka)

This shortlist is for enterprise IT and security teams with older on-premises estates that need multi-factor authentication where the application cannot provide it. It starts with Silverfort, SecureAuth and RSA SecurID, followed by Duo Security and Ping Identity PingID. Only Silverfort's official pages explicitly describe extending MFA to legacy apps with no agents or code changes, so the other entries note what is documented and what to confirm.

At a glance: the shortlist in order of fit for this use case
#ToolBest forKey featurePlatforms / deploymentPricingMore
1SilverfortSilverfortEnterprises protecting unmodified legacy apps and service accountsExtends MFA to legacy apps, command-line tools and OT infrastructure with no agents or code changesActive Directory, cloud IdPs, SaaS, legacy systems and OT (on-prem, hybrid, cloud and multi-cloud)See vendor pricing pageOfficial site
2SecureAuthSecureAuthTeams that need flexible deployment, including air-gappedWorks alongside Okta, Ping and Microsoft Entra IDCloud, hybrid, private SaaS and air-gapped infrastructureSee vendor pricing pageOfficial site
3RSA SecurIDRSA SecurityHigh-assurance organizations that need on-premises MFA and hardware tokensSecurID on-premises product lineCloud, hybrid and on-premises environmentsSee vendor pricing pageIntroduction
4Duo SecurityCiscoOrganizations that want MFA brokered over existing identity sourcesPhishing-resistant MFA described as needing no extra hardwareNot stated on official pagesSee vendor pricing pageIntroduction
5Ping Identity PingIDPing IdentityTeams adding MFA to logins, SSH and VPN accessIntegrates with Azure AD, AD FS, Windows login, Mac login and SSHSaaS service and mobile app for iOS and Android; multi-tenant SaaS or cloud containers with PingFederateSee vendor pricing pageOfficial site

1 Silverfort

By Silverfort

Silverfort is a runtime identity security platform that provides inline protection for human, machine and AI agent identities across Active Directory, cloud, SaaS, legacy systems and OT.

Why it is here: It sits first because its pages explicitly state that it can extend MFA to legacy apps, command-line tools and OT infrastructure with no agents or code changes.

Best for
Enterprises protecting unmodified legacy apps and service accounts
Key features
  • Extends MFA to legacy apps, command-line tools and OT infrastructure with no agents or code changes
  • Enforces identity security inline at the moment of authentication
  • Discovers and maps users, service accounts, non-human identities and AI agents
  • Can allow, challenge or block each access request
  • Integrates with Active Directory, cloud IdPs, SaaS, legacy systems and OT without system modifications
Limits
Documented as working through integration with the customer's IAM infrastructure. Teams with specific protocols or systems should check the vendor documentation for coverage.
Platforms / deployment
Active Directory, cloud IdPs, SaaS, legacy systems and OT (on-prem, hybrid, cloud and multi-cloud)
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 22 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

2 SecureAuth

By SecureAuth

SecureAuth is an identity security platform covering workforce, customer, partner and AI agent identities, with MFA, authorization and runtime enforcement.

Why it is here: It is second because it works alongside existing identity providers and documents cloud, hybrid, private SaaS and air-gapped deployment, which suits older estates with strict network boundaries.

Best for
Teams that need flexible deployment, including air-gapped
Key features
  • Works alongside Okta, Ping and Microsoft Entra ID
  • Risk-aware MFA based on behavior and context
  • Deployment in cloud, hybrid, private SaaS and air-gapped infrastructure
  • Complete audit trail of authentication, authorization and policy decisions
  • Workforce Authority with passwordless login and privileged access management
Limits
The pages we read do not state that it adds MFA to legacy applications or protocols without changes. Teams with older systems should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms / deployment
Cloud, hybrid, private SaaS and air-gapped infrastructure
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 22 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

3 RSA SecurID

By RSA Security

RSA provides identity and access management products, including the on-premises SecurID line, ID Plus and Governance & Lifecycle, for government, finance and high-assurance organizations.

Why it is here: It is third because SecurID is documented as an on-premises product line, and ID Plus covers cloud, hybrid and on-premises environments for organizations with older estates.

Best for
High-assurance organizations that need on-premises MFA and hardware tokens
Key features
  • SecurID on-premises product line
  • MFA with passcodes, biometrics or hardware authenticators
  • Passwordless authentication with FIDO2, biometrics and hardware tokens
  • Risk-based authentication using machine learning and behavioral analytics
  • FedRAMP-authorized identity security for government agencies
Limits
The pages we read do not state how MFA is applied to specific legacy applications or service accounts. Teams with those needs should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms / deployment
Cloud, hybrid and on-premises environments
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

4 Duo Security

By Cisco

Cisco Duo is an identity security and IAM platform that combines phishing-resistant MFA, SSO, passwordless login, a directory and device trust to secure workforce access.

Why it is here: It is fourth because it can broker access from identity sources an organization already has, but the pages we read focus on workforce sign-in rather than legacy protocols.

Best for
Organizations that want MFA brokered over existing identity sources
Key features
  • Phishing-resistant MFA described as needing no extra hardware
  • Can broker access from existing identity sources or act as a full IAM stack
  • Risk-based authentication that adapts in real time
  • Single sign-on and passwordless login from any device
  • Device trust with endpoint protection checks in the top edition
Limits
Documented for workforce access; the pages we read do not state support for legacy applications, protocols or service accounts. Teams with older systems should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms / deployment
Not stated on official pages
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

5 Ping Identity PingID

By Ping Identity

PingID is Ping Identity's cloud multi-factor authentication solution for workforce and partners, delivered as a SaaS service and a mobile app.

Why it is here: It is fifth because it documents integrations with Windows login, Mac login, SSH and VPNs and an offline MFA mode, which are relevant to older environments, but it does not claim unmodified legacy coverage.

Best for
Teams adding MFA to logins, SSH and VPN access
Key features
  • Integrates with Azure AD, AD FS, Windows login, Mac login and SSH
  • Out-of-the-box connectors for Microsoft 365 and VPNs
  • Offline MFA mode for local authentication without an internet connection
  • Methods include mobile push, OTPs, QR codes, magic links, FIDO2 biometrics and security keys
  • MFA applied to specific applications or by group membership
Limits
Documented as a cloud service with a mobile app, and the pages we read do not describe MFA for legacy applications that cannot be integrated. Teams with such systems should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms / deployment
SaaS service and mobile app for iOS and Android; multi-tenant SaaS or cloud containers with PingFederate
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 22 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

How we chose these tools

We looked at fit with the problem of enforcing MFA on applications, protocols and accounts that cannot support it natively, the capabilities each vendor documents, and the deployment and platform information on its official pages. We considered Thales SafeNet Trusted Access and left it out. Its documentation describes cloud and web access, delivered as a service, which is a different scope from this use case. Facts come from official vendor pages, and the date each page was checked is recorded with it.

The order reflects editorial fit for this use case. Tools are placed by how clearly the documentation describes enforcing MFA on unmodified applications and protocols without agents or code changes, and then by how well the documented deployment options and integrations suit older on-premises environments. It is not an overall judgment of one product against another. The list is built from documentation rather than product trials, so it reflects what vendors state, not how a deployment behaves in your environment. Confirm coverage for your specific protocols and service accounts before you commit.

Order used in this guide: Ordered by ability to enforce MFA on unmodified apps and protocols without agents or code changes.

Frequently asked questions

How do you add MFA to legacy applications that don't support it?

Silverfort's official pages say it can extend MFA to legacy apps, command-line tools and OT infrastructure with no agents or code changes. It does this by integrating with the existing IAM infrastructure at the moment of authentication.

Can MFA protect service accounts?

Silverfort documents discovering and mapping service accounts and other non-human identities without proxies or manual configuration. The other tools here do not state service account coverage on the pages we read, so check their documentation.

Which MFA tools work on-premises?

RSA documents SecurID as its on-premises product line and ID Plus across cloud, hybrid and on-premises environments. SecureAuth lists cloud, hybrid, private SaaS and air-gapped deployment options.

Can MFA work without an internet connection?

PingID documents an offline MFA mode that lets users authenticate locally without an internet connection. SecureAuth lists air-gapped infrastructure as a deployment option.

Sources. Facts on this page come from each vendor's official pages, checked on the dates shown (Asia/Dhaka):

Lockhelm is independent and not affiliated with the vendors listed. No vendor paid for inclusion or position. Product names belong to their owners. Features and prices change; confirm details on each official website.