LockhelmIntroductions to password, identity and access tools

Multi-factor authentication · 5 tools

Top 5 MFA tools for smart card and certificate-based sign-in

On this page
  1. Key takeaways
  2. Comparison table
  3. 1. Yubico YubiKey
  4. 2. Thales SafeNet Trusted Access
  5. 3. RSA SecurID
  6. 4. Token2
  7. 5. SecureAuth
  8. How we chose
  9. FAQ
  10. Request a listing

For certificate-based sign-in, Yubico YubiKey, Thales SafeNet Trusted Access and RSA SecurID are the first tools to look at, in that order. This shortlist is written for government contractors and enterprises that run PKI and need multi-factor authentication that fits smart card and PIV-style credentials. Each entry sticks to what the vendor documents, so you can see where a tool is a direct fit and where you should confirm details yourself.

Comparison table

At a glance: the shortlist in order of fit for this use case
#ToolBest forKey featurePlatforms / deploymentPricingMore
1Yubico YubiKeyYubicoFederal and regulated teams that need hardware-backed smart card sign-inYubiKey 5 Series supports FIDO2/WebAuthn, U2F, smart card, OpenPGP and OTPUSB-A, USB-C, Lightning and NFC form factors; works through any USB port or NFC readerVendor pricingIntroduction
2Thales SafeNet Trusted AccessThalesEnterprise IT teams that want policy-driven MFA and SSO for cloud and web accessPolicy engine enforces rules at user, group or application levelDelivered as SaaS with no infrastructure neededVendor pricingIntroduction
3RSA SecurIDRSA SecurityGovernment and high-assurance organizations that need on-premises or hybrid MFASecureID is the on-premises product line, while ID Plus covers SSO, MFA and directory services across cloud, hybrid and on-premises environmentsCloud, hybrid and on-premises environmentsVendor pricingIntroduction
4Token2Token2Organizations that want FIDO2 keys or standalone hardware TOTP tokensFIDO2 keys work with any WebAuthn service for passwordless loginWorks with services including Microsoft Entra ID, Google and AWS; Linux bridge tool availableVendor pricingIntroduction
5SecureAuthSecureAuthEnterprises that want continuous, risk-based authentication alongside an existing identity providerSessions are not trusted by default, with risk re-scored and step-up when neededCloud, hybrid, private SaaS or air-gapped infrastructureVendor pricingOfficial site
1

Yubico YubiKey

By Yubico · yubico.com

Best for: Federal and regulated teams that need hardware-backed smart card sign-in

The YubiKey is a family of hardware security keys from Yubico that protect access to computers, networks and online services with phishing-resistant authentication. The YubiKey 5 Series supports several protocols, including smart card.

Why it is here: It sits first because it is the only tool here whose documentation names smart card support alongside PKI authorization and FIPS validation.

Key features
  • YubiKey 5 Series supports FIDO2/WebAuthn, U2F, smart card, OpenPGP and OTP
  • YubiKey 5 FIPS Series meets AAL3 of NIST SP800-63B
  • FIPS 140-3 validated and described as DoD-authorized for both PKI and FIDO2
  • Works through any USB port or NFC reader without installing software
  • FIDO Pre-Reg delivers keys already enrolled
Watch out for
Yubico documents hardware keys and related services, so the identity provider and PKI back end you pair them with sit outside this entry. Teams with specific certificate lifecycle needs should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms
USB-A, USB-C, Lightning and NFC form factors; works through any USB port or NFC reader
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)
2

Thales SafeNet Trusted Access

By Thales · cpl.thalesgroup.com/access-management/safenet-trusted-access

Best for: Enterprise IT teams that want policy-driven MFA and SSO for cloud and web access

SafeNet Trusted Access is a cloud-delivered access management and authentication service from Thales that combines single sign-on, MFA and scenario-based access policies.

Why it is here: It sits second because it supports numerous authentication methods and can reuse schemes already deployed, which suits organizations adding access policy on top of existing authentication investments.

Key features
  • Policy engine enforces rules at user, group or application level
  • Contextual and adaptive authentication, including FIDO devices, push and pattern-based methods
  • Supports numerous authentication methods and can reuse schemes already deployed
  • Single-pane view of access events across the app estate
  • Supports passwordless authentication
Watch out for
The official pages describe the service in terms of cloud and web access and do not mention smart card or PIV support. Teams that need those credentials should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms
Delivered as SaaS with no infrastructure needed
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)
3

RSA SecurID

By RSA Security · rsa.com

Best for: Government and high-assurance organizations that need on-premises or hybrid MFA

RSA provides identity and access management products, including the on-premises SecurID line, ID Plus and Governance & Lifecycle, for government, finance and high-assurance organizations.

Why it is here: It sits third because it targets government and high-assurance organizations and offers both on-premises and cloud options plus FedRAMP-authorized identity security, though its pages do not name smart card support.

Key features
  • SecureID is the on-premises product line, while ID Plus covers SSO, MFA and directory services across cloud, hybrid and on-premises environments
  • Passwordless authentication using FIDO2, biometrics and hardware tokens
  • FedRAMP-authorized identity security for government agencies
  • Hardware authenticator sold as the iShield Key 2
  • Integrates with Microsoft Entra ID Plan 1 and Plan 2
Watch out for
The official pages list passcodes, biometrics, hardware authenticators and FIDO2, and do not describe smart card or PIV handling. Teams that need those credentials should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms
Cloud, hybrid and on-premises environments
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)
4

Token2

By Token2 · token2.com

Best for: Organizations that want FIDO2 keys or standalone hardware TOTP tokens

Token2 is a Swiss company that designs FIDO2 security keys and programmable TOTP hardware tokens for phishing-resistant, multifactor and passwordless authentication.

Why it is here: It sits fourth because its hardware is documented mainly around FIDO2 and TOTP, with smart card access mentioned only through an open-source Linux bridge for NFC and smartcard FIDO2 devices.

Key features
  • FIDO2 keys work with any WebAuthn service for passwordless login
  • Classic TOTP tokens are standalone and need no phone, app or cloud
  • Programmable tokens let users load their own seeds
  • Commercial FIDO keys are available with L1 and L2 certifications
  • token2-fido-bridge is an open-source tool for NFC and smartcard FIDO2 devices on Linux
Watch out for
The official pages do not document PIV or PKI certificate sign-in as a product capability. Teams that need it should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms
Works with services including Microsoft Entra ID, Google and AWS; Linux bridge tool available
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 21 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)
5

SecureAuth

By SecureAuth · secureauth.com

Best for: Enterprises that want continuous, risk-based authentication alongside an existing identity provider

SecureAuth is an identity security platform that covers workforce, customer, partner and AI agent access, with continuous authentication, per-action authorization and agent governance.

Why it is here: It sits last because its documentation centers on continuous authentication, token binding and AI agent governance rather than smart card or certificate credentials, though it offers flexible deployment including air-gapped infrastructure.

Key features
  • Sessions are not trusted by default, with risk re-scored and step-up when needed
  • Supports token binding and DPoP to bind tokens to the requesting device
  • Captures every authentication, authorization and policy decision for compliance and forensics
  • Supports delegated administration for partners and business units
  • B2B Authority supports customer-owned SAML or OIDC identity providers and SCIM 2.0 provisioning
Watch out for
The official pages do not document smart card or PIV sign-in. Teams that need those credentials should check the vendor documentation.
Platforms
Cloud, hybrid, private SaaS or air-gapped infrastructure
Pricing
See vendor pricing page (not quoted here; facts checked 22 November 2026, Asia/Dhaka)

How we chose these tools

We looked at three things: how closely each tool fits certificate-based sign-in with smart cards and PIV-style credentials, which capabilities the vendor documents, and what the vendor says about deployment and supported platforms. Tools whose documentation addresses smart card or PKI use directly come before tools that describe broader access management or authentication coverage. Where the official pages do not mention a capability, we say so in the limits note rather than assume it.

All facts come from official vendor pages, each read on a recorded check date. The order reflects editorial fit for this specific use case, explained in the "why here" line for each tool. It does not say any tool is better overall. The list is built from vendor documentation, not from product trials, so please confirm technical details with the vendor before you commit to a deployment.

Order used in this guide: Ordered by depth of PKI and smart-card support, closest fit first.

Frequently asked questions

Can a YubiKey be used as a smart card for PIV-style sign-in?

Yubico documents that the YubiKey 5 Series supports smart card among its protocols and describes the YubiKey as DoD-authorized for both PKI and FIDO2. Confirm the exact certificate workflow you need in Yubico's documentation.

Which tools on this list meet NIST AAL3?

Yubico states that the YubiKey 5 FIPS Series meets the highest assurance level, AAL3, of NIST SP800-63B. The other tools' pages we used do not make that statement.

Do these tools work for US Federal agencies?

Yubico says YubiKeys are positioned to help US Federal agencies meet Zero Trust and phishing-resistant MFA requirements. RSA offers FedRAMP-authorized identity security for government agencies.

Do I need a phone or app to use hardware tokens?

Token2 documents classic TOTP tokens as standalone, needing no phone, app or cloud. Yubico says the YubiKey works through any USB port or NFC reader without installing software.

Can I run MFA on-premises or in an air-gapped environment?

RSA lists SecurID as its on-premises product line, and its ID Plus platform covers on-premises environments. SecureAuth states it can be deployed on cloud, hybrid, private SaaS or air-gapped infrastructure.

Sources. Facts on this page come from each vendor's official pages, checked on the dates shown (Asia/Dhaka):

Lockhelm is independent and not affiliated with the vendors listed. The editorial order is unpaid. A vendor may buy one clearly labeled featured slot per guide, sold to only one company, and we still check its facts; see our disclosure. Product names belong to their owners. Features and prices change; confirm details on each official website.